Newcastle 1-0 Manchester City: Alexander Isak ends City’s quadruple dream as Eddie Howe’s side progress in League Cup

When the half-time whistle blew at St James’ Park, its deafening atmosphere that is so often eulogised about, was silent. Manchester City – even their supposed ‘second string’ – were dominant; Newcastle United’s reserve players were chasing shadows.

But whatever oranges were served at half-time had been injected with the most infectious of adrenaline. That injection? Brazilian midfield magnifico Bruno Guimaraes. With his introduction, the Magpies were back on song. The Lewis experiment – Messrs Hall and Miley – was binned.

Guimaraes’ arrival was the igniting spark that the hosts needed, having been outpassed, out-thought, outclassed in the opening 45 minutes.

City, who had rung the changes after Pep Guardiola had bemoaned their four away trips in 11 days, characteristically and expectedly took charge of proceedings after a frantic and high-octane first 10 minutes, with their slick pass-and-move hammering their tent pegs into the edge of the Newcastle penalty box.

Despite their dominance, clear-cut chances were few and far between. Julian Alvarez, the focal point up front, drew the game’s first save from a tight angle on 18 minutes, with his right-footed drive saved by the foot of the still-standing Nick Pope, and another flashing shot, this time from the left peg of the Argentine, whizzed past the opposite post on the half-hour.

When finally Newcastle were able to prise their backs from the wall, they burst forward at pace. Joelinton picked the pocket of Kalvin Phillips in midfield, before feeding Alexander Isak ahead of him. The Swede opened his body up, sliding in the onrushing Jacob Murphy down the right, but the winger, could not conjure the necessary composure not accuracy with his strike, which was repelled by the deputy goalkeeper Stefan Ortega.

But with the restart came a different Newcastle. Their press was ferocious; their mentality on the offensive.

They were duly rewarded on 53 minutes, when Guimaraes, so often the orchestrator, started the move, finding his compatriot Joelinton in a pocket of space, before driving into the box with menace and power. To the byline he went, and finally, he released a cross-shot that caught Rico Lewis asleep at the far post. Isak was alive, and his tap-in sent the Gallowgate End into a sea of ecstasy.

The aggression, the intensity, the work-rate of the Toon had gone up tenfold. And that is how you beat the treble winners.

With Newcastle’s newfound desire and fight, City were pinned back – rattled – with Guardiola having to turn to some of his star names on his substitutes bench to try and dig them out. Phil Foden, Matheus Nunes, Jeremy Doku… none of them could find that elusive equaliser as the Toon Army roared their heroes into the next round of the Carabao Cup.

Whatever Eddie Howe said to his players in the dressing room at half-time, he’ll be scrambling to remember and write down.

Newcastle’s first and second-half performances were night and day, but they display two important things.

The first, is how pivotal Guimaraes is to their system. He is the one to receive the ball on the half-turn when the pressure is on. He is the one to start attacking moves. He is the one to initiate the give-and-goes that set up Isak and the frontline for their easy finishes.

The second is the squad depth issue, which is particularly highlighted here against City, a side with similar riches to Newcastle, and a blueprint that the Magpies will be keen to copy in the coming seasons. Newcastle have had to contend with a drop-off in quality when it comes to resting their big names, and with a huge Champions League clash against Paris Saint-Germain next week, the fact that Isak came off injured, and Guimaraes had to come on, will not have done their fitness levels any favours.

The positive? The emergence of Tino Livramento, who marshalled Jack Grealish expertly down the Newcastle right, as a very able stand-in for captain Kieran Trippier at right-back.

The Magpies were being overrun in centre-field – not something that we can all too often – with the two youngsters, Lewis Hall and Lewis Miley, flanking Sandro Tonali, as City’s quality on the ball proved too much for the inexperienced trio, but with the introduction of the Brazilian Guimaraes, the balance changed quickly.

The former Lyon man brought composure, leadership and quality to the engine room, ably supported by his workhorse colleagues Joelinton and Tonali either side.

Newcastle: Pope 6, Livramento 8, Lascelles 7, Dummett 7, Targett 6, Hall 6, Miley 5, Tonali 6, Murphy 6, Joelinton 7, Isak 7.

Subs: Guimaraes 9, Gordon 7, Almiron 6, Anderson 6, Schar 6.

Man City: Ortega 6, Lewis 6, Akanji 6, Ake 6, Gvardiol 7, Gomez 6, Phillips 6, Kovacic 6, Bobb 7, Grealish 6, Alvarez 6.

Subs: Doku 6, Nunes 6, Foden 6.

18′: GOOD SAVE! City finally penetrate the Newcastle defence as Bobb advances at pace, with Alvarez’s decoy run taking the defender away from the youngster. Bobb eventually slides Alvarez in down the right side of the box, and the Argentine’s effort is stopped by the standing Pope’s foot.

41′: GREAT SAVE! St James’ erupts in a crescendo of noise as Newcastle break with purpose for the first time. The City defence is stretched as Joelinton picks Phillips’ pocket, Isak plays a ball into Murphy, who is in down the right, but his strike isn’t far enough in the corner, as Ortega saves! A great chance spurned!

53′: GOAL! It’s Alexander Isak who draws first blood for Newcastle! Whatever they had in their half-time oranges has clearly done the trick, with measured pass-and-move carving the City defence open. Guimaraes links up with Joelinton on the edge of the area, and the Brazilian powerfully drives into the box and feints to shoot. He eventually releases a cross-shot from a tight angle, and with Lewis asleep at the far post, Isak knocks home!

89′: CLOSE! City come closest, with Doku bursting inside and feeding the inverted Lewis, who drags a shot narrowly wide of the near post!