The Major Supreme Court Decisions in 2023

Question wording: The Clean Water Act is a federal law that prohibits the “discharge of pollutants” into “navigable waters.” Some people think that this should be read broadly, to include things like wetlands. Other people think that this should be read narrowly, to include only things like streams, rivers and lakes. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: California law prohibits the sale of pork from pigs that are kept in small cages. Some people think that such a law discriminates against commerce from other states because most pork comes from outside California. Other people think that such a law does not discriminate against commerce from other states. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: In 1981, a photographer took a photo of the musician Prince. The artist Andy Warhol made changes to this photograph and used that to create a series of famous prints. Some people think that when images are transformed like this, the original creator is not entitled to any payment. Other people think that the original creator is entitled to payment because the image is still recognizable. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: Some people think that large tech companies, such as Google, can be held responsible when their algorithm recommends certain content to users. Other people think that these companies cannot be held responsible for content recommended by the company’s algorithms if that content was posted by other users. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: Federal law states that social media companies are not responsible for hosting content that is posted by others. Some people think that social media companies can be held responsible for aiding and abetting terrorism for not removing content and accounts promoting terrorism. Other people think that they cannot be held responsible. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: Some people think that private colleges and universities should not be able to use race as a factor in admissions. Other people think that they should be able to. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: Some people think that public colleges and universities should be able to use race as a factor in admissions. Other people think that they should not be able to. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: Some people think that the language in the Constitution means that only state legislatures can regulate federal elections, without oversight from state courts. Other people think that state courts can exercise this oversight as they do in other areas. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: The Biden administration announced plans to give up to $20,000 in student loan forgiveness to people who make less than $125,000 a year. Some people think that the Biden administration overstepped its authority with this debt forgiveness plan. Other people disagree and think the Biden administration did not overstep its authority. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: Colorado law prohibits businesses, including creative and artistic businesses, from discriminating against gay customers. Some people think this violates business owners’ rights to free speech. Other people think this does not violate business owners’ rights to free speech. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: In 1978, Congress enacted a law that says that Native American children who are removed from their families should be placed with extended family members or foster homes of people who are also Native American. Some people think this law discriminates on the basis of race. Other people think it does not discriminate on the basis of race. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: One-fourth of Alabama voters are Black. Alabama recently created seven congressional districts, with only one of them being a majority-Black district. Some people think that the small number of districts in which Black voters are a majority violates Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, which bans racial discrimination in voting policies, and that the state should be forced to redraw the districts. Other people disagree and say that the original plan with one majority-Black district is lawful. What do you think? | Source: SCOTUSPoll

Question wording: A postal worker refused to work on Sundays for religious reasons. The Postal Service agreed to help him find co-workers to swap shifts with, but when he could not find any co-workers to swap with and did not show up to work multiple times, he was disciplined and then quit. Some people think that this is not religious discrimination. Other people think that this is religious discrimination and that the employer should have to accommodate his beliefs and should not have disciplined him. | Source: SCOTUSPoll